Spouses Ran PPP Fraud In Secret, Ga. Defendants Tell Jury - Mr. Mark Smith, LL.M., CLDP

A Georgia man and woman standing trial for charges that they helped orchestrate a scheme to illegally obtain $11 million in Paycheck Protection Program loans were unwittingly implicated in the fraud by their respective spouses, the defendants' lawyers told a federal jury Wednesday. Attorneys for Teldrin Foster and Carla Jackson, whom prosecutors say were instrumental in the 22-person fraud ring, argued during opening statements that both had in fact been bystanders, wrongly accused thanks to their close connections to the real perpetrators. Jackson's attorney, David Marshall, said that despite "all of these lawyers" the government assembled, he was confident there was "no evidence" his client — who is accused of using her business to help launder the proceeds of the loans — played any part in the scheme. Instead, Marshall continued, it was Jackson's ex-husband John Gaines who kept "secrets upon secrets upon secrets" from her. Not only did Gaines hide his involvement with the scheme, he said, but he also cheated on Jackson and fathered children out of wedlock prior to their divorce. "Carla Jackson committed no crime," Marshall said, adding the planned testimony of Gaines — who pled guilty to his role in the scheme last week — would "inject into this case more than the reasonable doubt required" to acquit Jackson. This week's trial is the culmination of a nearly 4-year-old investigation into the fraud ring the government said was masterminded by Duluth, Georgia's Darrell Thomas. According to prosecutors, Thomas recruited a wide cast of accomplices to file PPP loan applications during the first months of the COVID-19 pandemic. The program, enacted as part of 2020's CARES Act, was designed to provide immediate relief to business owners by doling out hundreds of billions of dollars so they could keep workers on their payroll during the initial shutdown from the virus. Thomas pled guilty to profiting immensely from the initiative using forged IRS papers for front businesses, raking in more than $14.7 million from the PPP and other pandemic relief programs. Originally set to begin Monday, the proceedings were delayed after Jackson and Foster's co-defendant Jerry Baptiste failed to appear in court. Federal marshals were dispatched to track down Baptiste, but he remained unaccounted for as of Tuesday morning, when U.S. District Judge J.P. Boulee elected to move into jury selection without him. The U.S. Department of Justice did not immediately have an update on Baptiste's status. In presenting the government's case Wednesday, the DOJ's Siji Moore painted a portrait of a sophisticated criminal enterprise with Thomas at its head. Below Thomas were operatives like Foster, Moore added, who helped prepare falsified IRS documents, while other members recruited agents to register front businesses. The proceeds were then laundered by businesses like Jackson's "that only existed on paper"; Moore said it had no bank transactions in the first months of 2020, a period of inactivity abruptly followed by a series of six-figure deposits. "This case is about Teldrin Foster and Carla Jackson's decision to participate in fraud during a time of national crisis," Moore told the jury, a contention backed up by "a long paper trail" of bank records, computer files and digital communications. Foster and Thomas had a relationship predating the scheme, Moore said, but key to its success was the fact that Foster's wife worked for the Internal Revenue Service. Gena Pyfrom-Foster — who pled guilty to using her post to further the conspiracy and is due to begin a 41-month prison sentence this summer — served as the group's inside contact who worked with Foster to create the fake documents, he said.  But Foster's attorney, Leigh Ann Webster, argued it was Foster's wife whose dirty hands stained her client. In Webster's telling, Pyfrom-Foster and Thomas engaged in the scheme behind Foster's back. Both had access to Foster's email account, which the government says was used to communicate the details of the fraud, constituting "significant evidence" that Foster was never involved. Thomas reportedly owed Foster tens of thousands of dollars from prior business ventures together, Webster said, leaving Foster to assume any money he received from the scheme was simply a belated repayment of those debts. "From the government's perspective, this story is simple," Webster said, adding "there's more — a lot more — to this story." The government is represented by Siji Moore of the U.S. Department of Justice's Fraud Section and Nathan Parker Kitchens, Tal C. Chaiken, Radka T. Nations, Sekret T. Sneed and Samir Kaushal of the U.S. Attorney's Office for the Northern District of Georgia. Carla Jackson is represented by David D. Marshall. Teldrin Foster is represented by Saraliene Durrett of Saraliene Smith Durrett LLC and Leigh Ann Webster of Strickland Webster LLC. The case is USA v. Thomas et al., case number 1:20-cr-00296, in the U.S. District Court for the Northern District of Georgia.